Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Michael S. Stagnitta
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Michael S. Stagnitta

M S Stagnitta Ins Agcy Inc

(631) 666-8350
87 Park Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706

On the corner of Union Boulevard and Park Ave. Across from the Bay Shore Train Station.

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
10am - 1pm
Call or text us 24 hours a day!


87 Park Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706


English, Spanish

**Online Quotes are not currently available. Please contact our office to speak with our experienced team to assist you with your auto insurance needs. ***

We here at the Michael S. Stagnitta State Farm Insurance Agency support our local businesses and charities so Let continue to support our local businesses like the Islip Animal Shelter while giving a forever home to the newest addition to your family you will receive a Michael S. Stagnitta bag full of fur baby goodies. We would also be proud to help protect the new edition to your family with our Trupanion Pet Insurance policy all you have to do is give us a call.

Welcome to the Michael S. Stagnitta State Farm Agency. Located here in the heart of Bay Shore NY. We are here to help protect you from the unexpected with over 35 years combined experience within the agency.

Whether its moving into a new home , getting into a new car or planning your future we can assist you with auto insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance, condo insurance, personal liability umbrella, personal articles policy (Jewelry, collectibles along with most of your valuable contents) and supplemental medical policies including our Health suplimental insurance policy and Trupanion pet insurance.

A priority here in our agency is protecting you and your loved ones with a variety of life insurance products personalized to your meet needs.

We are also proficient in protecting your small business by offering general liability insurance, contractor’s insurance, business auto insurance, commercial liability umbrella insurance, workers compensation insurance and employee non owned liability policy (ENOL).

We strive to provide outstanding customer service from Montauk to Manhattan including our surrounding neighbors, Islip, Central Islip, West Islip, Brentwood, Brightwaters, Babylon, North Babylon, West Babylon, Deer park, Dix hills and all of New York State.

Also proudly servicing the states of New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Connecticut.

Some of my credentials include:

  • Hofstra University-Hempstead NY B.A.

  • Licenses include: Series 7, 63, and 65. Property & Casualty as well as Life, & Health

  • 2000-2007 SR VP/Financial Executive at Citi/Smith Barney

  • Notary Public is on premises.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

Appliance maintenance to-dos for your home

Regular upkeep of all of your home’s appliances and big systems is a must-do that ensures these investments work well and have long, productive lives.

Tips for managing finances and expectations when living with adult children

Living with adult children back at home can be a great way for kids to save money, but it is important to stay mindful of your own finances.

Share the road with farm vehicles

Rural road driving might feel safe & relaxing but they are shared with farm vehicles & have risks. Here are tips to help when driving in the country.

View More Articles
Our mission is to approach and address each customer need individually and thoroughly with integrity and customer service excellence. Distinguishing ourselves from our competition and becoming a pillar of the community.
  • Come and visit with myself or one of my team members for your comprehensive insurance and financial review. Our team members will address each customer need individually to provide our policyholders with a personalized blueprint to achieve their objectives.

Claudia Aidenian State Farm Agent Team Member

Claudia Aidenian

Office Manager

I have been a State Farm professional since 2005.

I have been privileged to find a home as the manager here at the Michael Stagnitta State Farm Agency.

I am the youngest in a family of 6 woman. Being that I am the youngest I do know the importance of the Hospital Indemnity Policy and the Significant need for Life insurance.

I have seen a lot while working for this amazing company. Prior to my working for State Farm I was not aware of the importance of insurance.

Over the years I have come to see that insurance is not something that is forced upon us but it is something that we should all have. Not because its mandatory to have when buying a vehicle or home but because It offers protection from things that most of us are not aware we need protection for.

There is a recent addition to our family. A little fur baby named Luna. I am happy that I can offer her protection with pet insurance from Trupanion. Knowing I can provide her that protection is priceless to me and my family.


Maria Loja-Hugo

Account Manager

Fluent in Spanish and English, I am from Ecuador and came to the US when I was 8 yrs old. I was raised in Sunset Park, Brooklyn and moved to Islip, Long Island in 2005, when my son was born. 


I am a wife and working mom of 2  awesome and rambunctious teenagers, which is why I understand the need for Hospital Indemnity policies and Life Insurance  policies, knowing my family is insured allow me to sleep at night.


I enjoy yoga, kayaking and traveling, so a Hospital Indemnity policy and Personal Articles policy are a good fit for me.  I am fulfilled to know that as an insurance professional here at the Michael Stagnitta State Farm Insurance Agency I am helping to insure the  families, friends and neighbors of this wonderful community of Bay Shore and the surrounding areas.


Gaby Ruiz State Farm Agent Team Member

Gaby Ruiz

Our Agency

Learn more about our agency and the career opportunities with us.
Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.